Skip to content

The one best system…

October 24, 2010 pm31 12:24 pm

was the title of a book about American urban public education. It sits on my shelf, partially read.

My education “shelf” is actually quite short – a quarter of a shelf out of 30 something. There’s Small Schools by Mike and Susan Klonsky (read and reviewed), So Much Reform, So Little Change by Charles Payne, untouched, I really should read it. Pillars of the Republic by Carl Kaestle, great book about the early history of public education in America (I think Eric Foner was his advisor). Teacher Man, McCourt, unread. Accountability Frankenstein, Sherman Dorn, barely started (I’m going slow because I think he is pro-reform, and I’d rather not learn that that’s true). Playing for Keeps, Deb Meier et al, skimmed through. The Death and Life of the Great American School System, carried on many a trip, cover still not cracked. Diane Ravitch. An Incar pamphlet in defense of public education in Connecticut that I must have picked up 30 or so years ago. The Pressures of Teaching, a highly readable anthology of short essays by real teachers, edited by Maureen Picard Robins (so ok, I’ve only read a couple of the essays). It’s Not All Flowers and Sausages, by Miss Mimi, adorable, and between the blog and the book I’ve read most of it.

And that’s it. I’m not counting guides to the standards (THE standards? Ha!) Or Ed Psych books, or any of that sort of thing. And I’m counting no math books, no math teaching books. There’s a bunch more of those.

– – — — —– ——– —– — — – –

But this wasn’t supposed to be a post about my bookshelves (as proud of them as I may be). My point is, we don’t have one best system. We have different systems of education for different kids. And even in the big cities, we have multiple forms of education.

Let’s start by stripping away the Catholic schools. Their curriculum, how close is it to ours? The religion classes, the uniforms… Different culture, different education. And the other parochial schools, that probably fall all over the place.

Then the upscale private schools. Different class. Different books. Different expectations. Different culture.

And once we are left with just public schools, we have at least two, maybe three systems.  I only have a rough idea of the similarities and differences – but I am confident that the substance and style, the curricular content and social values, are distinct enough to support, at least roughly, these classifications:

At the fringes of Queens and on Staten Island, much of what happens as far as curriculum and culture looks, rumor has it, a bit suburban. Ethnically/racially these schools are less Black and Hispanic. At the high school level, this is the land of large schools with pep rallies and football. There is probably a range of achievement levels (mislabeled? ability levels), with honors classes in each grade. There may be functioning PTAs, perhaps in some cases with serious dough. This is not a world touched by school closings or the “turnaround” model. I hesitate to say more. I don’t teach there. They are saddled with the same nasty central administration that we have. But I suspect a different world overall.

In chichi parts of especially Manhattan there are schools that look more like the low end (socially) upscale private schools. They are probably more integrated than the schools on the fringe, but work with a clear upper middle class sense of place and status. In many the curriculum leans progressive (D2). Some support more of an honors model, some a more mixed academic model (heterogeneous grouping they call it, but given who goes to those schools in the first place…). Put Stuyvesant and Anderson at the non-heterogeneous extreme. The high schools in this group, with a few notable exceptions, are smaller, by choice. In any event these schools are distinguished by what they teach, and what they don’t teach. Tons of higher order thinking. Enriched content, whether project-y or hard. And less test prep. Extra curriculars. And in some cases some serious PTA involvement, including some serious cash. I’m sensing this is a land where school choice is popular.

In the Bronx and most of Brooklyn, in large parts of Queens, and in most of Manhattan above a distressingly mobile line, education looks different. The world looks different. There’s a lot more poverty. Streets, infrastructure more dilapidated. More crime. Different mix of stores selling a different mix of products. To poorer people. Overwhelmingly Black and Hispanic. The schools physically may not look that different from the other groups (though they may be less likely to have functioning playgrounds). But the curriculum is not even close to the same. Test prep ranges from moderate to mind-numbing. Extra curriculars are more limited. The culture has two extremes – out of control, or uniformed, disciplined, “yes sir, no sir.” These are the places where art and music, foreign language, even social studies gets cut out of the curriculum. These are the places where charter schools, the ultimate in New York for “yes, sir” and uniforms and long days and consequences and test prep til they puke, where charter schools are considered a good choice.  The comprehensive, larger elementary and middle schools get dumped on.

In high school effective “school choice,” after the massive mini-school-ization, is between the Academy for Medicine, Animation and Pataphysical Science on the one hand and the High School of the Shiny Object on the other, and it turns out that they both teach the exact same test prep and give away diplomas with the exact same credit recovery.

Personnel are different, too. New York City Teaching Fellows get jobs in the third group of schools. Most wash out. Those who stay, some try to move to the other parts of the system, some stick. Teach for America temporary teachers only teach in the third group, and usually for just two years. They are totally absent from the other parts of the system.

And of course NY-style Charters are only established in the neighborhoods with the third group of schools.

– – — — —– ——– —– — — – –

Now, it’s the one best system. Is it? Could it be? Is one part worth copying?

Ok, maybe. But let’s be careful with what we copy. School Choice in Manhattan produced so many nice options. School choice in the Bronx has been an excuse not to fix anything.

So forget the form. If we start thinking about what parts of the curriculum (not standards) can be exported from Staten Island or Manhattan, what parts of the socialization can be made common, then we might be back on track.

10 Comments leave one →
  1. Fred Klonsky permalink
    October 24, 2010 pm31 1:34 pm 1:34 pm

    A post on education books not read. I must do one of those.

    • October 24, 2010 pm31 10:27 pm 10:27 pm

      Put it deep down on your to do list. One day you’ll get to it.

  2. October 24, 2010 pm31 2:36 pm 2:36 pm

    Anyone who thinks they can create a curriculum without knowing a single kid who is going to be a student in that curriculum is in a state of sin… anyone who writes a curriculum and then doesn’t have the courage to walk into a random classroom and teach it for a year is in a state of cowardice.
    Every year I adjust the “curriculum” of my system to the thirty years of previous students, then about two weeks into the year, I realize that, as the Sesame Street folks would sing, “some of these things are not like the others…” and I start rewriting my curriculum for “this years kids”… I’m sure the folks 3000 miles away in Washington would fire me if they knew, but they don’t have time to come look, they have conferences to go to with college folks who will fill them with the next great revolution in education….

    I wish I had the courage and energy to keep up the fight you do.. I hide away in my classroom and hope I can win the students over to the beauty of calculus and stats..and in truth, I lose more battles than I win…but the victories I do have give me the courage to go one more year…

  3. October 24, 2010 pm31 6:22 pm 6:22 pm

    Thank you, thank you, thank you! Exactly!

    Also – Teacher Man by Frank McCourt – enh – I could of spent my time with better things….

  4. chaz permalink
    October 24, 2010 pm31 7:41 pm 7:41 pm

    Are you telling me that the DOE’s workshop model does not work for everybody? Don’t tell those non-educators at Tweed about that.

  5. October 24, 2010 pm31 8:50 pm 8:50 pm

    In terms of my book, skip to pp. 147-160. That’s where my specific proposals are.

    • October 24, 2010 pm31 10:28 pm 10:28 pm

      This week. I promise.

      For a few months I’ve been looking at the book’s cover, afraid that you think they’ve gone too far, but not that they should not have started.

      I’ll go straight to 147.

  6. October 24, 2010 pm31 10:34 pm 10:34 pm

    @Pat, thanks. I take that as high praise from someone who does what he does as well as you do.
    @RE, I also have heard that McCourt was not always, shall we say “pleasant” to his young charges. The book was an unwanted gift. I’m glad there is additional reason to let it just sit.
    @Chaz, actually, I would prefer some MORE consistent practice. But, and this is huge, adapted to the specific context. These groups of schoools, they are outgrowths of being in very different, very unequal neighborhoods. Same ideas can reasonably play out differently, depending on where.

    What they can’t do, or rather shouldn’t do, is give up on raising all boats. Good stuff on the east side and test prep in the ghetto means they are not trying.

  7. Read This permalink
    October 31, 2010 am31 11:14 am 11:14 am

    Teachers On Trial by James A. Gross 1988…amazing similarities!

  8. November 1, 2010 am30 9:44 am 9:44 am

    Reggio Emilia
    Free schools

    Virtual schools (many sorts)

    Homeschooling (many kinds)

    This is my (very quick) example list of currently existing, rather large ed systems. I’d like to live in a world where there are literally thousands. This is true for my kid, but most people only are aware of two-three.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: